A Model for Implementation of Intelligent Business Solutions on the Basis of the Level of BI Maturity: An Iranian experience

Main Article Content

Arash Ghashami https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7503-9813
Mahmood Alborzi https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6619-992X
Farzad Movahedi Sobhani https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4602-2710
Reza Radfar https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2535-4521


Business Intelligence Implementation, Business Intelligence Maturity, Information Technology


The purpose of this research is to provide a basis for choosing the approach to implementing business intelligence systems based on the maturity of the organization.
This research not only recommends considering the level of business intelligence maturity while planning for the implementation, but also recommends the use of IT governance levers in order to increase the level of efficient usage of such systems.

In this research, while analyzing the subject by experts in the Delphi Fuzzy method, these ideas have been reviewed and verified in nearly 109 organizations responding to the questionnaires. The result of this research is a fuzzy inference engine that suggest the best execution package required, by entering data on the size and maturity of the organization. Packages containing the appropriate implementation methodology, products at that maturity level and, consequently, IT governance processes and requirements to that level of maturity.


Download data is not yet available.
Abstract 285 | PDF Downloads 0


Abbaspour , Ghanbar . "Prioritizing Information Technology (IT) Enablers in Service Organizations by Fuzzy Multiple Criteria Decision Making (F-M.C.D.M)." BI Management Studies Volume 5, Issue 18, (Spring 2017): Page 169-193.

Aghae , Reza , Milad Aghaei, and Asghar Aghaei. "Identification and Interpretation of Key Factors Affecting on Management Information Systems." BI Management Studies Volume 4, Issue 15, (Spring 2016): Page 125-148.

Akhavan, Peyman, Maryam Philsoophian, and Mohammad Hossein Karimi Gavareshki. "Developing a knowledge management strategy model based on maturity level: A Fuzzy Delphi approach." Iranian Journal of Information Processing and Management Volume 32, Issue 2 (Winter 2017): 397-420.

Alinezhad, Alireza, and Ramin Hakimian. "Performance Evaluation of Information Technology (IT) Industries using a hybrid approach of SERVQUAL, DEA and FMCDM Case Study: System Group Co." BI Management Studies Volume 1, Issue 3 (Spring 2003): Page 19-46.

Azar, Adel, Mohammad Sangi, Mohammad Mahdi Izadkhah, and Ali Anvari. "Synergy Management Model of the Holding by Fuzzy Approach; The Role of Information Technology in its Implementation." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 7, Issue 1 (Spring 2015): Page 1-22.

Bakhshandeh, Somayeh , and Mohamad Hosein Rahmati. "The Investigation of Alignment of Business Intelligence capabilities and components in Conjunction with Creating Business Intelligence Benefits (case: SMEs of Tehran)." the Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 8, Issue 1 (Spring 2016): Page 27-46.

Burns, Tom, and G.M Stalker. Sociology of Organization: Structures and Relationships. Edited by Mary Godwyn, & Jody Hoffer Gittell. London: SAGE, 2012.

Cheng, C, and Y Lin. "Evaluating the best main battle tank using fuzzy decision theory with linguistic criteria evaluation. “.” European Journal of Operational Research 1421 (2002): 174-186.

Clavier, Pamela R., Hugo H. Lotriet, and Johan J. van Loggerenberg. "Business Intelligence Challenges in the Context of Goods- and Service-Dominant Logic." 45th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Hawaii: IEEE, 2012.

Cosic, Ranko, Graeme Shanks, and Sean Maynard. "Towards a Business Analytics Capability Maturity Model." 23rd Australasian Conference on Information Systems. Geelong, 2012.

Dastranj Mamaghani, Nasrin, and Peyman Akhavan. "Investigating Organizational Readiness of Implementation by Considering Knowledge Management Effective Success Factors." Iranian Journal of Information Processing and Management 26, Issue 3 (7-2011): 493-517.

Elbashir, Mohamed Z., Philip A. Collier, and Michael J. Davern. "Measuring the effects of business intelligence systems:The relationship between business process and organizational performance." International Journal of Accounting Information Systems, 2008: 135-153.

Ghazanfari, Mahdi, Mohammad Fathiyan, and Mojtaba Raeis Safari. "Measuring of information technology governance maturity in Iranian financial services industry Comparison between state & private bank sectors using the COBIT4.1 framework." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 3, Issue 6 (Spring 2011): Page: 63-88.

Hasanzadeh, Alireza, Leila Namdarian, and Shaban Elahi. "A model for service-oriented architecture (SOA) governance maturity." Iraninan Journal of Information Processing and Management Volume 27, Issue 3 (spring 2012): 681-697.

Hashemi, Seyyed Ali Akbari, Hasan Alvedari, Mohammad Reza Daraei, and Rohollah Razini. "A Model for the Assessment of Organizational Dashboard Development Using Business Intelligence Logic in Organizations." Bi Management Studies Volume 6, Issue 21 (Autumn 2017): Page 93-130.

Hossein Ronaghi, Mohammad, and Jafar Mahmoudi. "The relationship between corporate governance and IT governance in public organizations." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 7, Issue 3 (Autumn 2015): Page 615-634.

Jiang, James J., Gary Klein, Hsin-Ginn Hwang, Jack Huang, and Shin-Yuan Hung. "An exploration of the relationship between software development process maturity and project performance." Information & Management 41 (2004): pp: 279-288.

Khadivar, Ameneh, and Fatemeh Abasi. "KM Maturity assessment in 300 top Iranian company." Modern Researches in Decision Making Volume 1, Issue 3 (Autumn 2016): Page 23-42.

L. Zadeh, A. "The concept of a linguistic variable and its application to approximate reasoning." Information Sciences 8 (1975): 199-249.

Lahrmann, Gerrit, Frederik Marx, Robert Winter, and Felix Wortmann. "Business Intelligence Maturity: Development and Evaluation of a Theoretical Model." Proceedings of the 44th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Hawaii: IEEE, 2011.

Ludwig, L, and S Starr. "Library as place: results of a Delphi study." Journal of the Medical Library Association 933 (2005): 315-327.

Manian, Amir, Mosakhani Mosakhani, and Ali Zare Mirakabad. "Assessing the Maturity Level of Organization in Strategic Alignment between IT and Business (Multi-cut Case Studies: Barid, Caspian and Sepehr)." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 5, Issue 2 (Summer 2013): Page 171-186.

Mehrabi, Ali, Edris Mahmoudi, and Reza Alihosseyni. "Business Intelligence Maturity Assessment Using a New Hybrid Model." BI Management Studies Volume 4, Issue 15 (Spring 2016): Page 65-96.

Nazari Salari, Leila, Ameneh Khadivar , and Neda Abdolvand. "A model for analyzing the barriers of using Business Intelligence (BI) in the tourism industry of Iran, a mixed method approach." Modern Researches in Decision Making Volume 1, Issue 1 (Summer 2016,): Page 79-102.

Peterson, Ryan. "CRAFTING INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY GOVERNANCE." Information Systems Management, 2004: pp: 7-22.

Popovič, Aleš, Ray Hackney, Pedro Simões Coelho, and Jurij Jaklič. "Towards business intelligence systems success: Effects of maturity and culture on analytical decision making." Decision Support Systems Vol. 54 (2012): pp: 729-739.

Raber, D, F Wortmann, and R Winter. "Towards the Measurement of Business Intelligence Maturity." ECIS, 2013.

Raeesi Vanani, Iman, and Fatemeh Ganjalikhan Hakemi. "Designing an Adaptive Nuero-Fuzzy Inference System for Evaluating the Business Intelligence System Implementation in Software Industry." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 7, Issue 1 (Spring 2015): Page 85-104.

Raeis Safari, M., M. Ghazanfari, and M. Fathiyan. "COBIT A Suitable Framework for Measuring IT Governance in Organizations." Iranian Communication and Information Technology Volume 1, Issue 1 And 2 (1-2009): 55-65.

Rahmanimanesh, Mohammad, Mohsen Shafiei Nikabadi, Fatemeh Pourkarim, and Golafrooz Davoodifar. "Using Fuzzy Flowsort Inference System to Rank the Factors Leading to among Iranian Enterprises." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 9, Issue 4 (Winter 2018): Page 787-808.

Rajterič, Irena Hribar. "OVERVIEW OF BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE MATURITY MODELS." Management Vol. 15, Issue 1 (2010): pp. 47-67.

RANJAN, JAYANTHI. "BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE: CONCEPTS, COMPONENTS, TECHNIQUES AND BENEFITS." Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology, 2009: pp: 60-70.

Rezaeemanesh, Behrooz, Sina Mohammadnabi, and Saviz Mohammadnabi. "Knowledge Management Application in Measurement of Organizational Maturity." Iranian Journal of Information and Management 27, Issue 4 (2012): 985-1009.

Ribbers, Pieter M. A., Ryan R. Peterson, and Marylin M. Parker. "Designing Information Technology Governance Processes: Diagnosing Contemporary Practices and Competing Theories." 35th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. Hawaii: IEEE, 2002.

Rouhani, Saeed, and Sogol Rabiee Savoji. "An Assessment Model for the Success of Business Intelligence Tools." BI Management Studies Volume 4, Issue 15 (Spring 2016): Page 29-64.

Rouhani, Saeed, and Ahad Zare Ravasan. "A Model for Assessing Business Intelligence level of Enterprise Systems." BI Management Studies Volume 1, Issue 2 (Autumn 2013): Page 105-121.

Saghafi, Fatemeh, and Mehdi Fasanghari. "Comprehensive Interactive Maturity Model for Mobile government." Iranian Communication and Information Technology Volume 2, Issue 3 And 4 (8-2010): 27-40.

Sambamurthy, V., and Robert W. Zmud. "ARRANGEMENTS FOR INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY GOVERNANCE A THEORY OF MULTIPLE CONTINGENCIES." MIS Quarterly Vol. 23, No. 2 (1999): pp: 261-290.

Shafia, Mohammad Ali, Amir Manian, and Iman Raeesi Vanani. "Designing a Fuzzy Inference System for Predicting the Implementation Success of ERP Solution." Journal of Information Technology Management Volume 5, Issue 1, (Spring 2013): Page 98-106.

Skulmoski, G., J, F. T. Hartman, and j. Krahn. "The Delphi Method for Graduate Research." Journal of Information Technology Education 6 (2007): 1-21.

Sledgianowski, D, and J Luftman. "IT-Business Strategic Alignment Maturity: A Case Study." Journal of Cases on Information Technology, 72 (2005): pp102-120.

Tabatabaei, Seyyed ahmad, and Seyed Kamal Chaharsooghi. "Proposing a model for IT services-based assessment approach, based on IT Governance Model." Iranian Communication and Information Technology Volume 7, Issue 23 And 24 (12-2016): 53-62.

Taghva, Mohmmad Reza, and Payman Hajizadeh. "Measuring the Maturity of IT and Business Strategies Alignment in Organization: Case Study of SAIPA-Yadak Company." Journal of Information Science and Technology Volume 25, Issue 3 (2010): 481-504.

TDWI Team. BI Project Management. 2010.

Toghyani, Alireza, Ali Rajabzadeh, and Aliasghar Anvari Rostamy. "Designing of Decision-Making Model in Uncertainty Conditions." Modern Researches in Decision Making Volume 1, Issue 1 (Summer 2016): Page 189-216.

van der Raadt, B. "The relation between EA effectiveness and stakeholder satisfaction." Journal of Systems and Software 83 (2010): pp.1954-1969.

Wixon, B, and H Watson. "An emprical investigation of the factor affecting data warehousing success." MIS Quarterly 25 (2001): pp: 17-41.